Replacing door hinges might seem like a small task, but it can make a world of difference in the functionality and appearance of your doors. If your door is sagging, squeaking, or just not closing properly, the hinges are often the culprit. I’ve been there before, trying to open a stubborn door that grinds against the frame—trust me, it’s more than just an annoyance. Replacing door hinges is an easy and satisfying project that anyone can tackle with just a few basic tools.
In this guide, I’ll walk you through every step of the process. Whether you’re replacing old, rusty hinges or just updating to a new style, you’ll learn exactly how to get the job done right.
Tools and Materials You’ll Need:
Before we get started, gather these tools and materials:
- New door hinges (preferably the same size as your old ones)
- Screwdriver or drill
- Screws (usually come with new hinges)
- Hammer
- Chisel
- Utility knife
- Pencil
- Wood filler (if needed)

Step 1: Remove the Old Hinges
First things first—let’s get those old hinges off the door. I find that using a screwdriver is best because it gives you more control, but a drill can speed things up if you’re confident.
Start by propping the door slightly open and unscrewing the hinges from the door frame. Be sure to hold the door steady as you remove the last screw; otherwise, it might suddenly drop. If you’re working alone, use a doorstop or a stack of books to support the door.
Pro Tip:
- Keep a firm grip on the door as you work. If it feels heavy, don’t be afraid to ask for a helping hand—it’s better than having the door crash down!
Step 2: Prepare the Door and Frame
With the door off, take a good look at the old hinge mortises (the recessed areas where the hinges sit). If the old hinges were a different size or shape, you might need to adjust these areas to fit your new hinges. Use a chisel and hammer to carefully remove any excess wood, creating a flat, clean space for the new hinges.
I remember the first time I did this—it felt intimidating, but as long as you go slow and steady, you’ll be fine. Just tap the chisel gently and work in small increments. It’s not a race, and the cleaner the mortise, the better your new hinge will sit.
Pro Tip:
- Always check the fit of the new hinge before fully attaching it. Place it in the mortise and ensure it sits flush. If it doesn’t, chisel away a bit more wood until it fits perfectly.
Step 3: Attach the New Hinges to the Door
Now it’s time to attach the new hinges to the door. Place the hinge into the prepared mortise on the door, align it properly, and screw it in place. Make sure the hinge pins (the part that holds the two plates together) are aligned straight up and down.
This step might seem simple, but precision is key. Take your time to align the screws perfectly, as even a slight misalignment can cause the door to hang crookedly.
Pro Tip:
- Tighten the screws halfway first to check the hinge alignment, then tighten fully once you’re sure everything is lined up.
Step 4: Re-Hang the Door
With the hinges securely attached to the door, you’re ready to re-hang it on the frame. This part can be a bit tricky—trust me, I’ve had my fair share of fumbles. Align the hinges with their mortises on the door frame and start by inserting the top hinge screw first. This will help hold the door in place as you work on the others.
Once the top screw is in, go ahead and screw in the remaining hinge screws. Be sure to check that the door opens and closes smoothly. If it’s sticking or scraping, you might need to make small adjustments by loosening the screws slightly and shifting the hinges.

Step 5: Fine-Tuning and Finishing Touches
Now that the door is back in place, test it a few times to make sure it swings freely and closes properly. If you notice any squeaking, a little bit of lubricant on the hinge pins can work wonders. And if you see any gaps where the hinges don’t sit flush, you can fill them with a bit of wood filler to tidy things up.
When I replaced my door hinges, I also took the opportunity to update the door handles to match the new hinge finish. It’s these little touches that can really elevate the overall look of your doors.
Troubleshooting Common Issues:
- Door Doesn’t Close Properly: Check if the hinges are aligned correctly or if the mortises need adjusting.
- Hinge Screws Stripped: If a screw hole is stripped, fill it with wood filler or toothpicks dipped in glue before reattaching the screw.
- Door Is Crooked: Loosen the hinge screws slightly, reposition the door, and retighten.
The Difference It Makes
Replacing door hinges might seem like a minor update, but it can have a big impact on how your doors function and look. I remember the satisfaction I felt when I swung the door open for the first time after replacing the hinges—it was smooth, quiet, and looked great. It’s one of those projects that gives you an instant reward, and it’s a skill you’ll use again and again.
So, grab those tools and give it a shot. You’ll feel like a pro, and the difference will be noticeable every time you walk through that door. Plus, you’ll be saving money by doing it yourself—who doesn’t love that?
